Pentagon rebukes Sen. Clinton on Iraq

WORLD / America

Pentagon rebukes Sen. Clinton on Iraq

(AP)
Updated: 2007-07-20 09:15

WASHINGTON - The Pentagon told Democratic presidential front-runner
Hillary Rodham Clinton that her questions about how the US plans to
eventually withdraw from Iraq boosts enemy propaganda.

Democratic Presidential hopeful Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y.,
speaks before a meeting of the National Association of Counties at the
Richmond convention Center in Richmond, Va., Tuesday, July 17, 2007. [AP]

In a stinging rebuke to a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee,
Undersecretary of Defense Eric Edelman responded to questions Clinton
raised in May in which she urged the Pentagon to start planning now for
the withdrawal of American forces.

A copy of Edelman's response, dated July 16, was obtained Thursday by The
Associated Press.

"Premature and public discussion of the withdrawal of US forces from Iraq
reinforces enemy propaganda that the United States will abandon its
allies in Iraq, much as we are perceived to have done in Vietnam, Lebanon
and Somalia," Edelman wrote.

He added that "such talk understandably unnerves the very same Iraqi
allies we are asking to assume enormous personal risks."

Clinton spokesman Philippe Reines called Edelman's answer "at once
outrageous and dangerous," and said the senator would respond to his
boss, Defense Secretary Robert Gates.

Clinton has privately and publicly pushed Gates and Joint Chiefs Chairman
Peter Pace two months ago to begin drafting the plans for what she said
will be a complicated withdrawal of troops, trucks and equipment.

"If we're not planning for it, it will be difficult to execute it in a
safe and efficacious way," she said then.

The strong wording of the response is unusual, particularly for a missive
to a member of the Senate committee with oversight of the Defense
Department and its budget.

Clinton aides said the letter ignored important military matters and
focuses instead on political payback.

"Redeploying out of Iraq with the same combination of arrogance and
incompetence with which the Bush administration deployed our young men
and women into Iraq is completely unacceptable, and our troops deserve
far better," said Reines, who said military leaders should offer a
withdrawal plan rather than "a political plan to attack those who
question them."

As she runs for president, the New York senator has ratcheted up her
criticism of the Bush administration's war effort, answering critics of
her 2002 vote to authorize the Iraq invasion by saying she would end the
war if elected president.

If she wins, Clinton may find herself overseeing such a withdrawal
policy, but she is hardly alone in raising the issue.

Republican Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana warned Thursday at a hearing
that if US military leaders and Congress "are not prepared for these
contingencies, they may be executed poorly, especially in an atmosphere
in which public demands for troop withdrawals could compel action on a
political timetable."

Edelman's letter does offer a passing indication the Pentagon might, in
fact, be planning how to withdraw, saying: "We are always evaluating and
planning for possible contingencies. As you know, it is long-standing
departmental policy that operational plans, including contingency plans,
are not released outside of the department."

Edelman is the Undersecretary of defense for policy. He is also a former
US ambassador and one-time aide to Vice President Dick Cheney. During the
2004 campaign, Cheney told Iowa voters that electing the Democratic
ticket of John Kerry and John Edwards would risk another terrorist attack.

Kerry jumped to Clinton's defense, deriding what he called smear tactics
by the administration.

"They will say anything, do anything, and twist any truth to avoid
accountability," said the Massachusetts senator.

Top World News 

� 27 killed in Yunnan mud-rock flows

� Valerie Plame's lawsuit dismissed

� Two suicide attacks kill 37 in Pakistan

� Asbestos found in dust from NYC eruption

� Russian-British relations to develop normally, says Putin

Today's Top News 

� Hu urges global effort to resolve Darfur issue

� Economy grows at blistering pace

� Community plan eases prison pressure

� Nuke talks hit snag, extended by a day

� Six party talks to end present round

Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours

20071125 http://www.hellomandarin.net